|Ali Hamza Ahmad Suliman al Bahlul|
September 11, 1969 |
|Detained at||Guantanamo (since 2002)|
|Alternate name||Ali Hamza Ahmed Sulayman Ismail
Ali Hamza Ahmed Suleiman al Bahlul
Abu Annas al-Yemeni
|Status||detained at the Guantanamo Bay detention camp|
Ali Hamza Ahmad Suliman al Bahlul (born September 11, 1969, Hudaydah, Yemen) is a Yemeni citizen who has been held as an enemy combatant since 2002 in the United States Guantanamo Bay detention camp. He boycotted the Guantanamo Military Commissions, arguing that there was no legal basis for the military tribunals to judge him.
He was convicted in November 2008 of performing media relations for the Saudi Osama bin Laden, the founder of Al-Qaeda, and sentenced to life imprisonment, after a jury of nine military officers deliberated for less than an hour.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit overturned his conviction on January 25, 2013. The court ruled that the charges of which he was convicted were not recognized war crimes at the time he was accused of committing them.
Joint Task Force Guantanamo counter-terrorism analysts describe Ali Hamza Ahmad Suliman al Bahlul as al Qaida's public relations director. He is alleged to have created propaganda videos glorifying attacks against the United States. He set up a satellite receiver for Osama bin Laden, the leader of the terrorist organization, to listen to live radio coverage of the September 11, 2001 attacks in the United States, which al Qaida caused.
He faced charges before the first Guantanamo military commissions, before the United States Supreme Court ruled that they were unconstitutional under existing executive authority. In 2004 he was held in solitary confinement.
Official status reviews
Following the ruling of the Supreme Court of the United States in Rasul v. Bush the Department of Defense was instructed to set up a system where Guantanamo captives would be informed as to why they were being held. The DoD set up the Office for the Administrative Review of Detained Enemy Combatants (OARDEC). OARDEC conducted annual reviews from 2004 to 2008. Scholars at the Brookings Institute, lead by Benjamin Wittes, listed the captives still held in Guantanamo in December 2008, according to whether their detention was justified by certain common allegations:
- Ali Hamza Ahmad Suliman al Bahlul was listed as one of the captives who had faced charges before a military commission.
- Ali Hamza Ahmad Suliman al Bahlul was listed as one of the captives who the military alleges were members of either al Qaeda or the Taliban and associated with the other group.
- Ali Hamza Ahmad Suliman al Bahlul was listed as one of the captives who "The military alleges ... traveled to Afghanistan for jihad."
- Ali Hamza Ahmad Suliman al Bahlul was listed as one of the captives who "The military alleges that the following detainees stayed in Al Qaeda, Taliban or other guest- or safehouses."
- Ali Hamza Ahmad Suliman al Bahlul was listed as one of the captives who "The military alleges ... took military or terrorist training in Afghanistan."
- Ali Hamza Ahmad Suliman al Bahlul was listed as one of the captives who "The military alleges ... fought for the Taliban."
- Ali Hamza Ahmad Suliman al Bahlul was listed as one of the captives who "The military alleges ... served on Osama Bin Laden’s security detail."
- Ali Hamza Ahmad Suliman al Bahlul was listed as one of the captives who was a member of the "al Qaeda leadership cadre".
- Ali Hamza Ahmad Suliman al Bahlul was listed as one of the captives "currently at Guantánamo who have been charged before military commissions and are alleged Al Qaeda leaders."
- Ali Hamza Ahmad Suliman al Bahlul was listed as one of "36 [captives who] openly admit either membership or significant association with Al Qaeda, the Taliban, or some other group the government considers militarily hostile to the United States."
- Ali Hamza Ahmad Suliman al Bahlul was listed as one of the captives who had admitted "being [an] Al Qaeda leader."
Charged before a military commission
Bahlul faced charges before a Guantanamo military commission prior to the United States Supreme Court ruling in Hamdan v. Rumsfeld (2006) that the Bush Presidency lacked the constitutional authority to create military commissions that, without adequate justification, substantially deviated from the rules of procedure and evidence applicable at U.S. courts-martial. He was indicted along with Ibrahim Ahmed Mahmoud al Qosi.
Lieutenant Commander Philip Sundel, his first military defense attorney, described the difficulty in getting a security clearance for a translator to talk to his client. Sundel told CBS News: "There's virtually no chance he can get a fair trial."
Bahlul asked Peter Brownback, the president of the commissions, if he could represent himself. Al Bahlul and the question of whether detainees should be able to represent themselves were featured in the October 2007 issue of the Yale Law Journal in an article by Matthew Bloom entitled: "'I Did Not Come Here To Defend Myself': Responding to War on Terror Detainees' Attempts To Dismiss Counsel and Boycott the Trial". His most recent military lawyer is Major Thomas Fleener.
After the Supreme Court ruling, Congress passed the Military Commissions Act of 2006, to authorize military commissions at Guantanamo to hear and judge detainee cases. On February 9, 2008, Bahlul and Ibrahim Ahmed Mahmoud Al Qosi were charged before military commissions.
Carol Rosenberg of the Miami Herald, reported that Bahlul would be allowed to represent himself before the newly authorized military commissions, although he was not previously allowed to do so before the Presidentially authorized commissions. David McFadden of the Associated Press reported that only three reporters covered Bahlul's trial, associated with the Miami Herald, the Associated Press, and Reuters. The new law authorized detainees to represent themselves by choice.
Testimony of members of the "Buffalo Six"
In late October 2008, three of the men from the group known as the "Buffalo Six" testified at Bahlul's Guantanamo military commissions. They testified on having been shown a two-hour video that Bahlul produced.
On November 3, 2008, Bahlul was convicted of conspiring with al-Qaeda, soliciting murder and providing material support for terrorism. At his sentencing, he admitted he was a member of Al-Qaeda, and was sentenced to life imprisonment. Through a translator, Bahlul said, "We will fight government that governs America, We are the only ones on Earth who stand against you."
Rosenberg in the Miami Herald reported that Bahlul's military defense attorneys filed a 50-page appeal of his sentence on grounds of free speech. The appeal was the second filed with the Court for Military Commission Review. Bahlul had boycotted his military commission, so no defense was mounted. He also refused to participate in the appeal.
Rosenberg reported that the Obama Presidency has proposed a change to the process of appeals of the rulings and verdicts of military commissions. The proposed changes would have such appeals first heard by the Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces, which Rosenberg noted was a 58-year-old institution. In the current process, there is no appeal to rulings of the Court of Military Commission Review. Under the proposed changes, appeals could be taken up to the United States Supreme Court.
Jane Sutton, reporting for Reuters, wrote that when Al Bahlul's conviction was overturned it implied the highest profile trials, those against Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, and four other conspirators, also seemed more likely to face similar challenges. Al Bahlul's was the second of the seven Guantanamo convictions to be overturned, so far. Salim Ahmed Hamdan, who had only been convicted of "providing material support for terrorism" had his conviction overturned in 2012. Three of the other five individuals to be convicted had also only been convicted of "providing material support for terrorism".
In July 2014 the United States Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit sitting en banc vacated Bahlul’s material support and solicitation convictions as unconstitutional under the ex post facto clause. The D.C. Circuit vacated Bahlul’s remaining conspiracy conviction in June 2015, finding that conspiracy is not a crime under the international law of war. The three judge panel produced three opinions with Judge Karen LeCraft Henderson writing a forceful 85-page dissent.
On September 25, 2015 the D.C. Circuit vacated its June judgment and granted the Government's petition for rehearing en banc. The Circuit specifically directed the rehearing will consider the standard of appellate review and as to if Congress's attempts to define and punish war crimes transgresses the Article III powers of courts.
Isolation from the other captives
Rosenberg has reported that, following his conviction, Al Bahlul was separated from the other captives. She said that the Department of Defense (DOD) justified the isolation because the "Geneva Conventions ... forbids convicts from being held with war prisoners." The government insists that it can detain Bahlul indefinitely, although without a conviction he may be moved out of isolation.
- "Guantanamo Jury jails bin Laden media chief for life", The Guardian, 4 November 2008
- Jane Sutton (2013-01-25). "Court overturns another Guantanamo conviction". Miami, Florida: Reuters. Archived from the original on 2013-01-26. Retrieved 2013-01-26.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit threw out the conviction of Yemeni prisoner Ali Hamza al Bahlul, ruling that the charges of which he was convicted - conspiracy, providing material support for terrorism and soliciting murder - were not internationally recognized as war crimes when the acts were committed.
- Scott Higham, Joe Stephens, Margot Williams (May 2, 2004). "Guantanamo -- A Holding Cell In War on Terror: Prison Represents a Problem That's Tough to Get Out Of". Washington Post. Retrieved 2007-11-24.
- Benjamin Wittes, Zaathira Wyne (2008-12-16). "The Current Detainee Population of Guantánamo: An Empirical Study" (PDF). The Brookings Institute. Retrieved 2010-02-16. mirror
- Carol Rosenberg (2008-04-15). "Terrorist trials get thornier with boycott". Miami Herald. Retrieved 2008-04-18.
The boycott tactic is not new. A Yemeni man accused of making al Qaeda recruiting videos as Osama bin Laden's media secretary employed it in earlier trials since shut down by the U.S. Supreme Court. He was Ali Hamza al Bahlul, who in January 2006 waved a sign with a single Arabic word -- "muqata'a" ("boycott").
- Kathleen T. Rhem (2004-04-26). "Yemeni Detainee Asks to Represent Self, Admits to Being al Qaeda". American Forces Press Service. Retrieved 2007-11-24.
- Office of the Assistant Secretary of Defense (Public Affairs) (2004-04-26). "Third Military Commission Interrupted by Yemeni Detainee Request". U.S. Department of Defense. Retrieved 2007-11-24.
- Office of Military Commissions (2004-07-27). "USA v. Ali Hamza Sulayman al Bahlul" (PDF). U.S. Department of Defense. Retrieved 2007-11-24.
- "Gitmo Detainee: I Am Al Qaeda". CBS News. 2004-08-26. Retrieved 2007-11-24.
- "Osama Driver Arraigned At Gitmo". CBS News. 2004-08-25. Retrieved 2007-11-24.
- Guantanamo trials to start, Special Broadcasting Service, January 11, 2006
- Jane Sutton (2008-02-09). "US military charges two more Guantanamo captives". Reuters. Retrieved 2008-02-09.
- David McFadden (2008-11-01). "With US election, sun setting on Guantanamo trials". Associated Press. Retrieved 2008-11-01. mirror
- Carol Rosenberg (2008-10-30). "Ex-U.S. jihadists testify at Guantánamo terror trial". Miami Herald. Retrieved 2008-10-30.[dead link] mirror
- "Guantanamo jury convicts bin Laden's media man". Reuters. 2008-11-03. Retrieved 2008-11-03.
- "Bin Laden's video-maker gets life". BBC News. 2008-11-03. Retrieved 2010-04-23.
- Carol Rosenberg (2009-09-02). "Bin Laden aide's Gitmo conviction appealed". Miami Herald. Archived from the original on 2009-09-02.
- Recent Cases, 128 Harv. L. Rev. 2040, citing Al Bahlul v. United States, 767 F.3d 1 (D.C. Cir. 2014).
- Savage, Charlie (12 June 2015). "Guantánamo Detainee’s Conviction Is Thrown Out on Appeal". The New York Times. Retrieved 14 June 2015.
- Denniston, Lyle (12 June 2015). "Appeals court sharply narrows war crimes prosecutions". SCOTUSblog. Retrieved 14 June 2015.
- Denniston, Lyle (25 September 2015). "New, expanded look at war crimes courts". SCOTUSblog. Retrieved 26 September 2015.
- Bravin, Jess (12 June 2015). "Court Overturns Guantanamo Detainee's Conspiracy Conviction". The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved 14 June 2015.
- "Life sentence for al-Qaeda propagandist fails to justify Guantánamo trials", Andy Worthington website, 3 November 2008
- "Who Are the Remaining Prisoners in Guantánamo? Part One: The “Dirty Thirty”", Andy Worthington website, 15 September 2010