Curse of Rocky Colavito
The Curse of Rocky Colavito is a phenomenon that supposedly prevents the Cleveland Indians baseball team from winning, be it the World Series, the American League pennant, reaching postseason play, or even getting into a pennant race. Its origin is traced back to the unpopular trade of right fielder Rocky Colavito for Harvey Kuenn in 1960.
The 1960 trade between the Detroit Tigers and Cleveland Indians sent "The Rock", the home run champion of 1959 to the Tigers for Harvey Kuenn, batting champion of 1959. It was a unique trade between a home run champion, 42 home runs in '59, and a hitting champion, .353 batting average in '59. Fans in Cleveland were outraged by the betrayal of their GM Frank "Trader" Lane. In only 2 years at the Indians, Lane had taken a mostly successful 40-man roster and had traded away every single player he had inherited. Fans in Detroit were mostly happy about the trade.
Birth of the Curse
The idea of the curse was first presented in print by Terry Pluto, who had previously covered the Indians for The Plain Dealer. In his 1994 book The Curse of Rocky Colavito: A Loving Look at a 33-Year Slump, Pluto suggested that the trade, made by Indians general manager Frank Lane to blunt Colavito's popularity and salary demands, led to a stretch where the Indians did not finish the season within 11 games of first place from 1960 to 1993. By 1994, the team had not won a pennant since 1954 or a World Series since 1948.
In The Curse of Rocky Colavito, Pluto writes of many of the misfortunes that struck the Indians following the Colavito trade:
- Getting Colavito back in 1965, from the Kansas City Athletics, but having to give up pitcher Tommy John and outfielder Tommie Agee to the Chicago White Sox in a three-team trade. John, winner of two games in the major leagues to that point, would win another 286, mostly for the Los Angeles Dodgers and New York Yankees, and play on four teams that reached the World Series. Agee, still a prospect in 1965, would win the American League's Rookie of the Year award in 1966, and would be traded to the New York Mets, where his hitting and fielding would be a major factor in their 1969 World Championship season.
- Trading pitcher Jim "Mudcat" Grant to the Minnesota Twins in 1964, for Lee Stange and George Banks. Grant was 28 years old, hardly old for a pitcher, and had already won 67 games in his career. After the trade, he would win 78 more, including 21 in 1965, when he helped the Twins win their first pennant. He would later return to the Indians as a broadcaster.
- The alcoholism of pitcher Sam McDowell, who went from being one of the game's top pitchers in the 1960s to an unreliable pitcher who left the game at age 32. He would eventually stop drinking and become a counselor to athletes with drinking problems.
- The mental illness of first baseman Tony Horton, a power hitter who couldn't handle the stress of playing in the major leagues, and left the game in the middle of the 1970 season at age 25. Like McDowell, he would receive treatment and recover, but he never returned to baseball.
- The rushing of pitcher Steve Dunning to the major leagues. The second overall pick in the 1970 baseball draft, he was brought straight to the major leagues from Stanford University without ever pitching in the minors. Called up too soon, he quit baseball in 1977, at the age of 28, with a career record of 23 wins and 41 losses.
- The signing and injury of Wayne Garland. In 1976, Garland, a 25-year-old right-handed pitcher for the Baltimore Orioles, won 20 games and lost only 7. A free agent after that season, the Indians offered him a contract worth $2.3 million over 10 years. But he hurt his shoulder in his first spring training with the Indians, chose to pitch through the pain rather than have immediate surgery, and went 13-19 in 1977. He retired in 1980, at age 30, with a career record of 55-66.
- The 1984 trade of pitcher Rick Sutcliffe to the Chicago Cubs, along with two other players, for outfielders Joe Carter and Mel Hall and two others. Sutcliffe would help the Cubs win the National League Eastern Division title that year—winning the NL's Cy Young Award—and again in 1989. He won 35 games in just over two seasons with the Indians, and won 114 more after they traded him. Hall was a good hitter but a disappointment, and though Carter became one of baseball's top sluggers with the Indians, they never had a pitcher as good as Sutcliffe at the same time. Carter would be traded to the San Diego Padres in 1989 for catcher Sandy Alomar and second baseman Carlos Baerga, possibly the best trade in the Indians' recent history, as Alomar and Baerga would be major cogs in their 1990s success. The Padres would trade Carter to the Toronto Blue Jays, where he would lead them to back-to-back World Series wins, including 1993, when his home run won the Series.
- The 1987 baseball preview issue of Sports Illustrated magazine. Following a surprising 84-win season for the Indians in 1986, the cover showed Indians sluggers Carter and Cory Snyder, and carried the words "INDIAN UPRISING" and the sub-headline, "Believe it! Cleveland is the best team in the American League!" The Indians lost 101 games that year (worst in Major League Baseball), though some believe that the curse that led to this collapse was "The Dreaded SI Cover Jinx."
- The 1993 spring training boating accident that killed relief pitchers Steve Olin and Tim Crews and nearly killed starting pitcher Bob Ojeda. Reliever Kevin Wickander was so grief-stricken at the loss of Olin that he was traded in mid-season and never regained his effectiveness, so the Indians essentially lost four pitchers due to one accident.
Since the book's publication in 1994, Pluto has written two sequels: "Burying the Curse" in 1995 and "Our Tribe" in 1999, the latter insisting the curse was still in place.
Despite the "evidence" of a curse on the team, Colavito has denied ever placing one.
Prior to the publication of Pluto's book The Curse of Rocky Colavito, there had been another explanation for the Indians' difficulties, one that came after the 1954 World Series but preceded the 1960 Colavito trade. The Indians fired manager Bobby Bragan in 1958. According to the story, Bragan walked out to the pitcher's mound at Cleveland Municipal Stadium, and placed a curse on the Indians, saying they would never win another pennant. Bragan, however, always denied that such a thing happened.
In 1994, the year Pluto's book was published, the Indians moved out of aging, crumbling Municipal Stadium and into the brand-new Jacobs Field. They were just one game behind the White Sox in the newly created American League Central Division when a strike put an end to the season. Despite the abrupt end, this was the first time the Indians had genuinely been in a pennant race since 1959, Colavito's last season before being traded away.
In the years since, the Indians have enjoyed tremendous success: 7 division titles (including 5 in a row) and 2 American League pennants. However, disappointing failures in the post-season have demonstrated that a curse may still loom over the ball club.
- In the strike shortened 1995 season, the Indians won 100 games in a 144-game season, finishing a record 30 games ahead of the second place Kansas City Royals. They swept the Boston Red Sox in the Division Series and beat the Seattle Mariners in a six-game League Championship. They appeared in their first World Series in 41 years, facing the Atlanta Braves. Despite being heavily favored, the Indians lost in 6 games, including getting 1-hit in the final game. In Atlanta's five trips to the World Series during the decade, Cleveland would be the only American League team they would defeat.
- In 1997, the Indians again found themselves in the World Series, this time facing the Florida Marlins, a team that was only established five seasons earlier. A see-saw battle ensued and the series went to a Game 7. In what has gone down as a classic in World Series history, the Indians scored first and led the Marlins 2-1 with one out in the bottom of the ninth inning. But reliever José Mesa was unable to get the last two outs, as the Marlins tied the game, and then won it in the bottom of the eleventh, 3-2. The Indians have not been to the World Series since then, while the Marlins won another championship in 2003. Mesa was then involved in a personal feud with former teammate Omar Vizquel five years after his lackluster performance in the series.
- In 1998, they again won the Central Division, but lost the American League Championship Series to the New York Yankees, despite being up two games to one with Games 4 and 5 at home.
- In 1999, they again won the Central Division but lost the Division Series to the Boston Red Sox, dropping the last three games after winning the first two (and despite having game 5 at home, where they won the first two games). The failure to win a World Series despite 5 straight division titles led to the firing of manager Mike Hargrove. The Indians have not made the playoffs in consecutive years since then, nor have they had consecutive winning seasons since 1994-2001.
- In 2000, the Indians, after falling behind in the Central Division, attempted to settle for the Wild Card. Entering the final day of the season, they were 1 game behind the Seattle Mariners for the AL Wild Card - a win and a Mariners loss would have forced a 1-game playoff for the Wild Card. Although the Indians won their game, the Mariners did as well and won the Wild Card. The Indians finished 90-72, 2.5 games better than that year's World Series champs the New York Yankees - and thus would have won the AL East, whether the leagues were divided into 2 or 3 divisions.
- In 2005, the Indians took a 92-63 record into the final week of the season with a firm grip on the wild card spot only to lose 6 of their last 7 games and lose the Wild Card to Boston (two of those losses were to the Tampa Bay Devil Rays, now called the Tampa Bay Rays).
- In 2006 and 2007, the Indians cut Brandon Phillips in order to retain Ramón Vázquez. Vazquez was later cut by the Indians, while Phillips became a stand-out player in Cincinnati, becoming a 30-30 member in 2007, winning 3 Gold Gloves (2008, 2010, 2011), a Silver Slugger Award (2011) and becoming an 2-time All-Star (2010, 2011).
- In 2007, the Indians led Boston three games to one in the American League Championship Series, with AL Cy Young winner CC Sabathia pitching the closeout game at home. But Boston rallied to win Games 5, 6, and 7, outscoring Cleveland 30-5 to secure the AL pennant. The Red Sox would go on the win the World Series for the second time in a four-year span.
- In 2009, two former Indian pitchers CC Sabathia and Cliff Lee started Game 1 of the 2009 World Series
- In 2011, the Indians were 30-15 on May 23 and had a 7-game lead in the AL Central but failed to capitalize. Their final record was 80-82 and were 15 games out of first place behind the Detroit Tigers.
- In 2013, The Indians finished the season going 21-6 in the month of September including a 10 game winning streak to end the season and clinch the Top Wild Card spot only to lose the one game playoff to the Tampa Bay Rays
- Cleveland sports curse
- Curse of the Bambino
- Curse of the Billy Goat
- Curse of the Black Sox
- Curse of the Colonel
- Merkle's Boner