Judges' Trial

File:Justice Case Testimonial.jpg

A witness testifies in the Judges' Trial

The Judges' Trial (or the Justice Trial, or, officially, The United States of America vs. Josef Altstötter, et al.) was the third of the 12 trials for war crimes the U.S. authorities held in their occupation zone in Germany in Nuremberg after the end of World War II. These twelve trials were all held before U.S. military courts, not before the International Military Tribunal, but took place in the same rooms at the Palace of Justice. The twelve U.S. trials are collectively known as the "Subsequent Nuremberg Trials" or, more formally, as the "Trials of War Criminals before the Nuremberg Military Tribunals" (NMT).

The defendants in this case were 16 German jurists and lawyers. Nine had been officials of the Reich Ministry of Justice, the others were prosecutors and judges of the Special Courts and People's Courts of Nazi Germany. They were—amongst other charges—held responsible for implementing and furthering the Nazi "racial purity" program through the eugenic and racial laws.

The judges in this case, heard before Military Tribunal III, were Carrington T. Marshall (presiding judge), former Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of Ohio; James T. Brand, Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of Oregon; Mallory B. Blair, formerly judge of the Third Court of Appeals of Texas; and Justin Woodward Harding of the Bar of the State of Ohio as an alternate judge. Marshall had to retire due to illness on June 19, 1947, at which point Brand became president and Harding a full member of the tribunal. The Chief of Counsel for the Prosecution was Telford Taylor; his deputy was Charles M. LaFollette. The indictment was presented on January 4, 1947; the trial lasted from March 5 to December 4, 1947. Ten of the defendants were found guilty; four received sentences for lifetime imprisonment, and six received prison sentences of varying lengths. Four persons were acquitted of all charges.

Indictment

1. Participating in a common plan or conspiracy to commit war crimes and crimes against humanity;
2. War crimes through the abuse of the judicial and penal process, resulting in mass murder, torture, plunder of private property.
3. Crimes against humanity on the same grounds, including slave labor charges.
4. Membership in a criminal organization, the NSDAP or SS leadership corps.

Count 4 applied only to Altstötter, Cuhorst, Engert, Joel (with respect to the SS) and to Cuhorst, Oeschy, Nebelung, and Rothaug concerning the NSDAP leadership. Both organizations had been found criminal previously by the IMT.

Count 1 was dropped: the court declared the charge to be outside its jurisdiction. Judge Blair filed a dissenting opinion that stated that the court should have made a statement that the Military Tribunals of the NMT in fact did have jurisdiction over charges of "conspiracy to commit war crimes and crimes against humanity".

All defendants pleaded "not guilty".

Defendants

• 

  Josef Altstötter

• 

  Paul Barnickel

• 

  Hermann Cuhorst

• 

  Karl Engert

• 

  Günther Joel

• 

  Herbert Klemm

• 

  Ernst Lautz

• 

  Wolfgang Mettgenberg

• 

  Günther Nebelung

• 

  Rudolf Oeschey

• 

  Hans Petersen

• 

  Oswald Rothaug

• 

  Curt Rothenberger

• 

  Franz Schlegelberger

• Wilhelm von Ammon.JPG

  Wilhelm von Ammon

Name	Sentence
Josef Altstötter	5 years, incl. time already served; released 1950; died 1979 in Nuremberg
[[{{{1}}}]]	acquitted; died 1966 in Munich
[[{{{1}}}]]	acquitted; died 1991 in Kressbronn am Bodensee
[[{{{1}}}]]	mistrial declared due to illness; died 8 September 1951
[[{{{1}}}]]	10 years, incl. time already served, released January 31, 1951; died May 12, 1978
[[{{{1}}}]]	lifetime imprisonment; commuted to 20 years released 1956. time of death unknown
[[{{{1}}}]]	10 years, incl. time already served-released January 1951; died 1979 in Lübeck
[[{{{1}}}]]	10 years, incl. time already served; died 1950 in Landsberg Prison
[[{{{1}}}]]	acquitted; died 1970 in Seesen
[[{{{1}}}]]	lifetime imprisonment; commuted to 20 years released 1956; died September 12, 1980 in Neuss
[[{{{1}}}]]	acquitted; died in 1963
Oswald Rothaug	lifetime imprisonment; commuted to 20 years and released 22 December 1956; died 1967 in Cologne
Curt Rothenberger	7 years, incl. time already served; released 1950. died 1959 in Hamburg
Franz Schlegelberger	lifetime imprisonment; released 1950 for "Health reasons"; died 1970 in Flensburg
[[{{{1}}}]]	10 years, incl. time already served; released January 31, 1951 by John J. McCloy; died 1992
[[{{{1}}}]]	committed suicide 1946 after the indictment, but before the beginning of the trial.

The highest-ranking officials of the Nazi judicial system could not be tried: Franz Gürtner, Minister of Justice died in 1941; Otto Georg Thierack, Minister of Justice since 1942, had committed suicide in 1946, and Roland Freisler, the President of the People's Court since 1942, was killed in a 1945 bombing raid on Berlin. Another who was alive but not tried was Hans Globke (died 1973).

All convicts were found guilty on all charges brought before them, except Rothaug, who was found guilty only on count 3 of the indictment, while he was found not guilty on counts 2 and 4. However, the court commented in its judgment that:

"By his manner and methods he made his court an instrumentality of terror and won the fear and hatred of the population. From the evidence of his closest associates as well as his victims, we find that Oswald Rothaug represented in Germany the personification of the secret Nazi intrigue and cruelty. He was and is a sadistic and evil man. Under any civilized judicial system he could have been impeached and removed from office or convicted of malfeasance in office on account of the scheming malevolence with which he administered injustice."

The public considered the sentences generally too low. Most of the convicts were released already in the early 1950s; some (Lautz, Rothenberger, Schlegelberger) even received retirement pensions in West Germany. The guide to German law entitled Das Recht der Gegenwart is still being published under the name Franz Schlegelberger (ISBN 3-8006-2260-2).

The Judges' Trial was the inspiration for the 1961 movie Judgment at Nuremberg, starring Spencer Tracy, Burt Lancaster, Richard Widmark, Marlene Dietrich, Maximilian Schell, Judy Garland, Montgomery Clift, Werner Klemperer and William Shatner.

References

• Trial proceedings from the Mazal Library.
• Description of the trial from the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum.
• The Justice Trial