New York gubernatorial election, 1994

New York gubernatorial election, 1994

November 8, 1994

135px Candidate George Pataki Mario Cuomo Party Republican Democratic Running mate Betsy McCaughey Stan Lundine Popular vote 2,488,631 2,364,904 Percentage 48.8% 45.4%

County results

Governor before election Mario Cuomo Democratic Elected Governor George Pataki Republican

The New York gubernatorial election of 1994 was an election for the state governorship held on November 8, 1994. The election resulted in the defeat of Democratic incumbent Governor Mario Cuomo by Republican George Pataki. The win was one of the most notable of the "Republican Revolution" that year.

Primaries

Democratic

Democratic candidates

• Incumbent Governor Mario Cuomo
• Political Activist Lenora Fulani
• National Chairman of CORE Roy Innis (Effectively Withdrew – July 14, 1994)

• 

  Governor
  Mario Cuomo

While Governor Mario Cuomo's approval ratings throughout 1993 and towards 1994 were slipping (usually under 40%), no major names appeared or sought to challenge him for the Democratic nomination. Only two candidates announced their intention to challenge Cuomo; Lenora Fulani, who had been the nominee of the New Alliance Party for Governor in 1990 and for President in 1988 and 1992, and Roy Innis, the National Chairman of the Congress of Racial Equality. Ultimately Innis did not turn in any petitions though Fulani, despite facing a small challenge to her own petitions, made it onto the ballot.

However, despite succeeding on making it onto the ballot, Fulani's bid was generally considered a losing effort with no hope of keeping the nomination away from Cuomo. Cuomo for his part refused to join her in any debates and, like many other Democrats, questioned whether Fulani was actually seeking the Democratic nomination or merely attempting to convince African-American voters to move over to the New Alliance Party; these views were rather quickly legitimized by Lenora Fulani herself. Most African-American politicos of note however would continue to support Mario Cuomo for the nomination, with the notable exception of Adam Clayton Powell IV. Fulani was also far outstripped when it came to fundraising, raising a paltry $93,000 to Cuomo's $6 million.

Despite fears among some that African-Americans voters, blaming Cuomo for former New York Mayor David Dinkins's loss to Rudy Giuliani due to his administration's response to the Crown Heights riot and criticism of Dinkins's efforts to handle it, Cuomo defeated Fulani by a 58.9% margin in the Democratic primary on September 13.

Democratic Gubernatorial Primary Results
Party		Candidate	Votes	%
	Democratic	Mario Cuomo	548,762	79.45
	Democratic	Lenora Fulani	141,918	20.55
Total votes			690,680	100.00

Republican

Republican candidates

• College Professor and 1990 Conservative Party Gubernatorial Nominee, Herbert London
• Former Ambassador to France, Evan G. Galbraith
• State Senator, George Pataki
• Former Representative, Bill Green (Withdrew – July 31, 1994 – Endorsed Richard Rosenbaum)
• Former State Party Chairman, Richard M. Rosenbaum

Race to the Convention

Initially most expected Senator Al D'Amato to be the Republican and Conservative party nominee for Governor in 1994, and began what looked like the beginnings of a campaign late in September when he attacked Mario Cuomo's record as Governor, claiming that New York had become "the taxasaurus and spendasaurus capital of the nation." However less than a month later D'Amato had definitively chosen not to run, feeling that the Republican party might take control of the Senate in the coming Midterm elections, which would make him Chairman of the Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs. After considering several candidate D'Amato, in conjunction with the State Party Chairman William Powers decided to endorse the candidacy of State Senator George Pataki, who it was thought could mend the growing rift between the party's moderate and conservative factions.

However, before even D'Amato made his decision to forgo seeking the Republican nomination for Governor, former gubernatorial candidate Herbert London declared on October 5. Running on a platform of tax cuts, reductions in state Medicaid and welfare payments and social conservatism, London was critical of both Cuomo and D'Amato, the later especially given his support of pork barrel politics while also espousing support for fiscal conservatism. However even after D'Amato had withdraw and thus had allowed for campaign funds to become available to other candidates, but by mid-January only had just under $4,000 in donations left out of about $54,000 raised despite his considerable base of supporters. Because of this and his social conservatism, many Republican party leaders began to consider him a sure-loser if put up against Cuomo who would drive many swing voters back towards the Democratic nominee.

Evan Galbraith, a businessman from Manhattan and former ambassador to France under the Reagan Administration, decided to explore running for the Republican nomination on January 4, and nearly instantly obtained endorsements from several notable figures, among them Henry Kissinger and William Buckley. Galbraith was considered by some as an alternative to London, holding similar positions (Galbraith wished to cut property and individual taxes in half, to reduce welfare spending, and to reinstate the death penalty) but at the same time managing to appeal to a larger base of moderates who would be key to winning the election. Galbraith had also previously been a candidate for governor in 1990, but his candidacy was taken to court, where it was declared that he was ineligible due to not having lived in New York for the required five years. Galbraith would finally formally declare on April 29, but by this time most conservatives had coalesced around either London or Pataki.

State Senator George Pataki formally declared his candidacy on March 14, but had been actively preparing for a campaign since the previous fall with the support of D'Amato and William Powers. While Pataki on paper at least appeared as a unifying candidate capable of appealing to both conservative and moderate Republicans, Senate Majority Leader Ralph Marino refused to support his nomination, angry over Pataki's association with Change – New York which had worked to prevent his reelection. There was also concern over Pataki's position on the abortion issue, with both Pro-Life and Pro-Choice organizations not being satisfied as to his "middle-ground" approach.

Former Representative Bill Green declared his candidacy on March 18, hoping to become the moderate alternative to Pataki and London, claiming he was conservative on fiscal issues while "sensibly compassionate" on social issues. His bid was almost instantly fatally wounded however when Michael Long, the Chairman of the Conservative Party, made it clear that he did not think Green could be nominated by them, possibly resulting in a rerun of the 1990 Gubernatorial Election where the Republican and Conservative candidates split the vote. However Green remained confident that, if nominated, he could pull enough votes together from the center that he could potentially defeat Cuomo, even if the Conservatives nominated their own ticket.

Former State Party Chairman Richard Rosenbaum was the last to declare on March 23 with a platform very similar to that of Bill Green but went even further, supporting Medicaid-financed abortions and tighter restrictions on guns. He also managed to create a much larger campaign chest of about $1.2 million (dwarfing that even of George Pataki) and decided against trying for an automatic ballot spot through the convention process, opting instead to directly petition for a place on the ballot; Rosenbaum, a Republican of the Rockefeller mold, had no illusions as to his chances of attaining the required 25% of the vote to succeed in doing so. Rosenbaum also decried the Republican party's efforts to work with the Conservative party, considering it "a recipe for losing", and sought to bring the state Republican party as a whole back towards the center.

J. Patrick Barrett, a businessman from Syracuse who was expected for some time to also join the race, dropped out on May 20 when he came to the conclusion that he could not obtain the support of 25% of the delegates to the Party state convention, which would have put him on the ballot for the September 13 primary election.

At the Republican Party state convention Pataki won the overwhelming support of the delegates present with Herbert London, the runner-up, falling short of the required 25% to automatically obtain a place on the party's primary ballot despite the support of Senate Majority Leader Ralph Marino. Controversy was stirred when supporters of Bill Green intended to change their vote from Green to London so as to possibly put him above the 25% threshold for automatic inclusion in the primary, but were prevented by party leaders who declared the vote final. Even had the entirety of Green's vote had gone to London however, he would have needed the support of some of Galbraith's delegates in order to have done so.

Republican State Convention Vote
Party		Candidate	Votes	%
	Republican	George Pataki	-	72.40
	Republican	Herbert London		22.10
	Republican	Evan Galbraith		2.80
	Republican	Bill Green		2.60
	Republican	Scattering		0.10
Total votes			'	100.00

From the Convention to the Primary

London, Galbraith and Green were all initially determined to petition to be on the primary ballot on September 13, but efforts were made to try and assuage any additional conflict within the party's nomination process. In return for his support, Herbert London was nominated for the position of Comptroller, allowing for Pataki to secure much of London's support within both the Republican and Conservative parties. A few days later on May 31, Bill Green would withdraw so as not to potentially split the vote of moderate Republicans with Richard Rosenbaum and endorse him.

With the support of almost the entire party behind him however, George Pataki managed to easily win the primary on September 13 by a 51% margin. Richard Rosenbaum would endorse Pataki the next day.

Republican Gubernatorial Primary Results
Party		Candidate	Votes	%
	Republican	George Pataki	273,620	75.60
	Republican	Richard M. Rosenbaum	88,302	24.40
Total votes			361,922	100.00

Conservative

Conservative Gubernatorial Primary Results
Party		Candidate	Votes	%
	Conservative	George Pataki	17,649	78.40
	Conservative	Robert G. Relph, Sr.	4,862	21.60
Total votes			22,511	100.00

Independence

Independence candidate:

• Republican Party State Chairman, Richard M. Rosenbaum – (Initial Nominee – Withdrew September 14 – Endorsed George Pataki)
• Businessman Tom Golisano – (Nominated – Added to Ballot September 28)

Libertarian Nomination

The original Libertarian candidate was New York City radio personality Howard Stern, who announced his candidacy for governor on his nationally syndicated radio show on March 22, 1994 on a platform of reinstating the death penalty, letting road crews work only at night, stagger highway tolls to prevent traffic jams, and to resign from office as soon as these goals were accomplished. Shortly thereafter the majority of state Libertarian Party members (there were only around 600 active members at the time) worked to draft Stern to run on their ticket, most considering him their best option to attain for the party automatic ballot access. Stern won the party's nomination by a two-thirds majority on the first ballot at their state convention on April 23, 1994.

Libertarian State Convention Vote
Party		Candidate	Votes	%
	Libertarian	Howard Stern	287	75.33
	Libertarian	James Ostrowski	34	8.92
	Libertarian	Norma Segal	24	6.30
	Libertarian	Dottie Lou Brokaw	22	5.77
	Libertarian	Joseph Brennan	10	2.63
	Independent	Scattering	4	1.05
Total votes			381	100.00

Later however, Stern refused to file the financial disclosures required by law of any party seeking to hold public office; he filed suit against the state of New York arguing the law violated his right to privacy and freedom of association. When the court denied his petition for injunction, Stern called a press conference on August 4, 1994 and withdrew from the election. However Howard Stern had in the months since his nomination also found himself increasingly strained from the state Libertarian party's leadership, having refused to communicate with them effectively or to aid them in collecting the 15,000 signatures needed to put the party on the ballot. Some had even argued that Stern should have simply let the case drag on until the party's nominees were put on the ballot on October 3, where he could then have withdrawn while his name would have remained on the ballot and would not be able to be removed.

Robert L. Schulz, a political activist from Queensbury, New York, replaced Stern on the statewide ballot. Stern's running mate, Stan Dworkin of Westchester County, remained on the slate as candidate for Lieutenant Governor.

General Campaign

Though early on in the election Cuomo led by as much as ten points, Pataki was eventually able to tie him due to his difficulty in defending his record. Pataki promised to cut income taxes by 25 percent which appealed to voters in an economic downturn.

One key issue in the election was capital punishment. Cuomo had long been a staunch opponent of the death penalty while Pataki supported it. In the 1980s and early 1990s most New Yorkers supported capital punishment due to high crime rates. Republican ads pointed to the case of Arthur Shawcross, a multiple murderer convicted of manslaughter who was paroled by New York in 1987 and committed additional murders while on release (during the time Cuomo was governor). This revelation caused a significant loss of support for Cuomo.

Polling

Source	Date	Pataki (R)	Cuomo (D)	Golisano (IF)
Buffalo News	Nov. 6, 1994	38%	42%	5%
Marist Institute	Nov. 3, 1994	40%	43%	7%
New York Daily News	Nov. 3, 1994	36%	50%	7%
New York Post/FOX-TV	Nov. 2, 1994	32%	46%	-
Quinnipiac College	Nov. 1, 1994	31%	44%	7%
New York Times	Oct. 31, 1994	34%	44%	-
New York Daily News/WNBC	Oct. 30, 1994	42%	43%	-
New York Post/FOX-TV	Oct. 30, 1994	40%	36%	-
New York Times/WCBS-TV	Oct. 7, 1994	44%	41%	-
Quinnipiac College	Oct. 2, 1994	38%	42%	-
Marist Institute	Oct. 2, 1994	44%	38%	-
WROC-TV/WIXT-TV	Sep. 16, 1994	41%	35%	-
New York Post/Buffalo News	Sep. 11, 1994	43%	41%	-

Results

While the race was very close overall, Pataki won by running up huge margins outside of New York City. Cuomo won only one county outside of the Five Boroughs, Albany County.

New York gubernatorial election, 1994

Party		Candidate	Votes	%	±%
	Republican	George Pataki	2,156,057	41.43%
	Conservative	George Pataki	328,605	6.31%
	Tax Cut Now	George Pataki	54,040	1.04%
	Total	George Pataki	2,538,702	48.79%	+27.44%
	Democratic	Mario Cuomo	2,272,903	43.68%
	Liberal	Mario Cuomo	92,001	1.77%
	Total	Mario Cuomo	2,364,904	45.45%	-7.72%
	Independence	Tom Golisano	217,490	4.18%	N/A
	Right to Life	Robert T. Walsh	67,750	1.30%	-2.10%
	Libertarian	Robert L. Schulz	9,506	0.18%	-0.43%
	Socialist Workers	Lawrence Lane	5,410	0.10%	-0.21%
Majority			1,001,674	21.15%	+17.81%
Turnout			5,203,762
	Republican gain from Democratic

See also

• Governorship of George Pataki