Soviet Census (1937)
The Soviet Census held on January 6, 1937 was the most controversial of the censuses taken within the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics. The census results were destroyed and its organizers were sent to the Gulag as saboteurs because the census showed much lower population figures than anticipated.
After the First All-Union Census of the Soviet Union of 1926, the next census was planned to be held in 1933. On March 15, 1932 the formal commission on census organization, chaired by Valerian Osinsky was created by the Statistical Commission (Tsentral'noye Upravleniye Narodno-Khozyaystvennogo Uchyota, TsUNKhU) of Gosplan. On 22 April 1932 Sovnarkom adopted the decision On Conducting the all-Union Census in December 1933. On 15 April 1933 Sovnarkom moved the date for the census to the beginning of 1935. On 23 June 1934 Sovnarkom further delayed the census to January 1936. On 15 June 1935 the census date was moved to December 1936. Finally the census was conducted on January 6, 1937.
The multiple delays were most probably explained by the reluctance to show the catastrophic demographic results of collectivization and the Famine of 1932-1934, including the Holodomor. The Soviet leadership had fanned great expectations of population growth.
On 26 January 1934 Joseph Stalin reported to the 17th Congress of the All-Union Communist Party (b) as one of the main achievements "Growth of population from 160.5 millions in the end of 1930 to the 168 millions in the end of 1933". On 1 December 1935 Joseph Stalin made a speech, on the Meeting of Kolkhozniks with the Soviet and Party leaders:
|“||Everybody says that the material situation of workers has dramatically improved, that life has become better and more fun. It is of course true. But this has led the population to breed much faster than in the old days. The birth rate is higher, the death rate is lower and the pure population growth is far stronger. It is of course good and we welcome it. [Jolly murmurs in the auditorium.] Now every year we have a population growth of three million souls. It means that every year we grow as much as the whole of Finland. [Everybody laughs.]||”|
Combining his reports, one could have expected to have a population of about 180 million in 1937.
Official statistics based on the registered birth and death rates implied that the 1937 census should show a population of 170-172 million. On 21 September 1935 Sovnarkom adopted a decision On the organization of registration of natural population changes (О постановке учета естественного движения населения) most probably authored by Stalin:
|“||The organs of registration were often used by the class enemies who had sneaked in there (priests, kulaks, whites) and made their own counterrevolutionary saboteurs work to deliberately hide population growth by registering the same deaths multiple times.||”|
In fact, as discussed by A. G. Volkov, the idea that a significant number of people received multiple death certificates for the same person is absurd. On the other hand, not registering deaths, especially those who died during the 1930s famines and prison inmates, was common. For example, during the Holodomor, starving peasants tried (despite the official ban) to escape to the cities where they could earn or beg for food. Many of them died in the streets. In 1933, the street-cleaning service of Kiev picked up 9,472 dead bodies. Only 3,991 of them were officially registered while 5481 were disposed of without formal registration according to the instructions of the prosecutor's office.
The official commission for the preparation of the census was formed on 16 September 1935. It included:
- Vyacheslav Molotov, the Chairman of Sovnarkom
- Lazar Kaganovich, Narkom for transport
- Anastas Mikoyan, Narkom for the food industry
- N.K. Antipov, Vice Chairman of Sovnarkom;
- Nikolai Bulganin, Chairman of Mossovet
- Emmanuil Kviring, Vice Chairman of Gosplan
- I.A. Kraval, the chief of TsUNKhU
- A.S. Popov, deputy to the chief of TsUNKhU.
Later the commission was joined by
All the documents related to the census were prepared by TsUNKhU and edited personally by Joseph Stalin. A.G. Volkov speculates that never in modern history was such a routine technical matter as a census so micromanaged by such high officials.
A comparison between the two variants is shown in the table below:
|TsUNKhU proposal||Stalin's edit|
|1||Relations with the person that provides the main income (wife, son, aunt, foster child, etc.)||removed|
If temporarily absent then:
|3||If lives temporarily state "lives temporarily"||removed|
|4||Sex (male - 1, female - 2)||1||Sex (male, female)|
|5||How many years since birth? For children younger than one year - months? Younger than one month - days?||2||How many years or months since birthday|
|7||Mother tongue||4||Mother tongue|
|8||If foreign citizen then of what state?||7||Citizen of what state?|
|9||Was born here?||removed|
|12||Where do you study? Name of school, courses, etc. For the children going to a nursery, kindergarten, etc. state "kindergarten", "nursery", etc.||9||In what school do you study - primary, secondary or tertiary?|
|10||What grade are you in?|
|13||Where have you studied? Name of the highest school (those graduated state grad., those who have not graduated state the grade or class they dropped)||11||Have you graduated from secondary or tertiary school?|
Type of occupation in present
|14||What social group do you belong: workers, white collars, kolkhozniks, individual farmers, artisans, people of free professions, priests of a cult or nonworking elements?|
|13||Place of work (name of the enterprise, kolkhoz, office)|
|16||If you have income not from the occupation state what type of income (pension, scholarship, from rent, etc.)||removed|
|17||If have no own income then who provides for you (Number of the person on the list and if not present state occupation, position and type of the enterprise)||removed|
|18||If married then for how many years?||6||Are you married?|
While his Soviet contemporaries[who?] praised Stalin's clarity and brevity in the design of these forms, modern scholars[who?] have observed a significant dumbing-down of the original proposals. A lot of information, e.g., about the social structures and income, and migration, could not be deduced from the new forms. Some questions (like the social category) were extremely vague and allowed different interpretations. Volkov argues it was done deliberately. Stalin removed the double accounting (of those present at the time of census and of those permanently living at an address), thus significantly reducing the accuracy of the calculations. It was coupled with a very maladroit time for the census: the night of January 5–6 – that is, the eve of Russian Orthodox Christmas, when people are extremely mobile.
The main new question introduced by Stalin was the question about religion. According to Volkov, Stalin expected the great majority of people to self-identify as atheists.
The census was held on January 6, 1937; in addition to the general census in the cities, towns and villages, a special census was held by the NKVD in the Gulag camps and among the border guards; by the Red Army, which took a census of military personnel; and the railroad, which took a census of passengers. When the data was first processed, it soon became obvious that the final enumeration would be no more than 162 million people. The worst disagreement between the expected and the obtained data were in Kazakhstan, Ukraine, North Caucasus and the Volga region, the areas that were the strongest hit by the Soviet famine of 1932-1934. Also, despite the expected number of living prisoners of the Gulag to be 4 million, only 2.6 million were accounted for.
On January 11 the chief of TsUNKhU Kraval sent telegrams requesting a total recount of a whole settlement if any doubt arose that somebody might be missing there. Still, despite the total recount in 25,000 settlements, only 4,887 previously unenumerated persons were found. The preliminary result of the census, reported to Stalin in the middle of March 1937, was 162,039,470 people, much lower than the "criminally decreased" registered numbers of 170-172 million or Stalin's expectation of 180 million people.
Another serious blow was a very high percentage of people who stated that they were religious. 55.3 million or 56.7% of those who provided answers stated they were religious (the question was asked only of people older than 16 years old), 42.2 million stated they were atheists and around 1 million refused to give an answer. Historian V. B. Zhiromskaya stated that people expected to be persecuted if they declared themselves as belonging to a religion but considered the answer to be important: If many people would say they are religious, the authorities would have to open the churches, was a common attitude. The Soviet authorities were so upset by the results of the census that they did not include a question on religion in any future censuses.
In March 1937 the four main statistical professionals working on the Census in TsUNKhU – the chief of the Sector for Population, Mikhail Kurman; chief of the Census Bureau, Olimpy Kvitkin; his deputy, Lazar Brand; and the chief of the Sector for transportation and communication, Ivan Oblomov, were arrested and imprisoned. Soon they were joined by the Chief of TsUNKhU, Ivan Kraval, and the chiefs of most of the regional statistical centers. Many statisticians, newly appointed in place of those arrested, were soon arrested themselves. There is evidence that many managers appointed to lead the statistical organization tried to avoid starting their new jobs in desperate attempts to escape persecution.
On 25 September 1937 there was a special Sovnarkom decision proclaiming the census invalid and setting a new one for January 1939. A Pravda editorial stated that the "enemies of the people gave the census counters invalid instructions that led to the gross under-counting of the population, but the brave NKVD under the leadership of Nikolai Yezhov destroyed the snake's nest in the statistical bodies".
|“||Some workers of the old Gosplan thought that during the second Five-Year Plan (1933-1938) the annual growth of population was three to four million people. It was a fantasy or worse.||”|
The new Soviet Census (1939) showed a population figure of 170.6 million people, manipulated so as to match exactly the numbers stated by Stalin in his report to the 18th Congress of the All-Union Communist Party. No other censuses were conducted until 1959.
Today there is a consensus[by whom?] that the results of the 1939 census were adjusted (0.5 to 1.5 million persons were added to the reported population). Some historians[who?] consider the 1937 census the only more or less reliable source of demographic data for the period 1926-1959. However, demographers do not consider it as such. The data became influential for evaluating the number of victims of the Great Purge, World War I, and the 1930s famines, including the Holodomor.
- A. G. Volkov Census of 1937 Facts and Fictions originally published in Перепись населения СССР 1937 года. История и материалы/Экспресс-информация. Серия "История статистики". Выпуск 3-5 (часть II). М., 1990/ с. 6-63
- Ye. M. Andreyev, L. Ye. Darsky, and T. L. Kharkova On the trails of the deleted census Originally published in Население Советского Союза. 1922-1991. М.: Наука. 1993. с. 23-29.
- Сталин И.В.Вопросы ленинизма.Изд.10-е.М.: 1938. С.572.
- Совещание передовых комбайнёров и комбайнёрок СССР с членами ЦК ВКП(б) и правительства 1 декабря 1935 года. М.,1935.С.118.
- V.B. Zhiromskaya On the religiosity of people in 1937 (using the census data) "Исторический вестник", №5 (1, 2000)(Russian)
- All-Union population Census, Pravda 27 July 1938.
- Сталин И. В. Отчетный доклад на XVIII съезде партии о работе ЦК ВКП(б) 10 марта 1939 г. М.: 1939. p. 24.
- e.g., Barbara A. Anderson and Brian D. Silver. 1985. "Demographic Analysis and Population Catastrophes in the USSR," Slavic Review, 44(3): 517-36; Steven G. Wheatcroft 'More Light on the Scale of Repression and Excess Mortality in the Soviet Union in the 1930s Soviet Studies Vol. 42, No. 2 (April, 1990), pp. 355-367.
- "Demographic catastrophes of the 20th century", a chapter from Demographic Modernization in Russia 1900–2000, ed. A. G. Vishnevsky, 2006 (ISBN 5-98379-042-0)
- Stanislav Kulchytsky, "How many of us perished in Holodomor in 1933", Zerkalo Nedeli, November 23–29, 2002. Available online in Russian and in Ukrainian
- Tsaplin V.V Statistics of stalinism victims in 30-ies, Voprosy istorii, 1989, N 4. pp. 177—178.
- Catherine Merridale, "The 1937 Census and the Limits of Stalinist Rule," The Historical Journal, Vol. 39, No. 1 (March, 1996), pp. 225-240.