Homicide of Vince Foster
Vincent Walker Foster, Jr. (January 15, 1945 - July 20, 1993) was a Deputy White House Counsel during the first term of President Bill Clinton, and also a law partner and friend of Hillary Rodham Clinton. He was last seen alive inside the White House, and all surveillance recordings which would have shown him leaving the grounds have vanished. His death was nevertheless ruled a suicide, a finding questioned by non-governmental investigators asserting a cover-up as well as US Attorney Miguel Rodríguez, who resigned from the Starr investigation alleging a widespread cover-up.
Vince Foster was found dead in Fort Marcy Park off the George Washington Parkway in Virginia, outside Washington, D.C., on July 20, 1993. Foster's death was concluded to have been a suicide by inquiries and investigations conducted by the United States Park Police, the Department of Justice, the FBI, the United States Congress, Independent Counsel Robert B. Fiske, and Independent Counsel Kenneth Starr.
The FBI "was requested by the United States Park Police (USPP), Washington, DC to assist them in their ... investigation" of the death of Vincent Foster. The FBI participated in the investigation by Independent Counsel Robert Fiske where, with Fiske's attorneys "agents of the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) questioned 188 persons and reviewed and analyzed thousands of documents."
Independent Counsel Kenneth Starr relied on "experienced investigators with extensive service in the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI)". Starr's final Report on the death of Vincent W. Foster consists of two volumes totaling 137 pages. United States Congressional hearings did not investigate the circumstances of Foster's death but specifically confined its inquiry into whether the White House was guilty of "improper conduct" during the course of "the Park Service Police investigation into the death."
After a three-year investigation, Starr concluded that Foster's death was a suicide. CNN stated on February 28, 1997, "The Starr report refutes claims by conservative political organizations that Foster was the victim of a murder plot and coverup," but "despite those findings, right-wing political groups have continued to allege that there was more to the death and that the president and first lady Bill and Hillary Clinton tried to cover it up." The final report is The Report on the Death of Vincent W. Foster, Jr., by the Office of Independent Counsel in Re: Madison Guaranty Savings & Loan Association.
Allegations of cover-up by lead investigator
Kenneth Starr's at-the-time lead investigator, US attorney Miguel Rodriguez, emphatically disagreed with Starr's conclusion that Foster committed suicide, referring to photographs and medical testimony suggesting a second gunshot wound on Foster's neck, evidence he asserts Starr suppressed. Concerning the cover-up, he wrote in his resignation letter, “As an ethical person, I don’t believe I could be involved in what they were doing.”
James Norman, former senior editor at Forbes Magazine, discussed and wrote about Foster having a Swiss bank account and possible espionage. An FBI interview report by agent Russell Bransford and a handwritten note from the Office of Independent Counsel found at the National Archives refer to Foster's Swiss bank account.
The comments of Patrick Knowlton, a grand jury witness who had been at the park where Foster's body was found, were included as part of Starr's Report over Starr's objection. Judge John D. Butzner wrote to Judges Peter Fay and David Sentelle after Knowlton submitted a motion that his comments be included as part of an appendix to the final report, "I suspect that if we deny this motion we will be charged as conspirators in the cover-up," and concluded "I suggest we let the motion and attachments speak for themselves." Judge Fay wrote that Knowlton contradicted "specific factual matters and takes issue with the very basics of the report" filed by Starr. Knowlton's comments were ordered included as part of the official report on September 26, 1997. Two days later, Starr filed a 9-page motion to appeal that the comments by Knowlton not be included in the report. The next day, Starr's motion was denied and Knowlton's comments were included as part of the final official Report on the Death of Vincent W. Foster.
John H. Clarke, attorney for Patrick Knowlton, argued that by using the FBI, the Office of Independent Counsel employed "the very agency it [was] designed to be independent from, the Justice Department." Clark further stated "The investigation under the auspices of ... Mr. Fiske was little more than an FBI investigation. Publicly available official federal government records indicate that throughout the 16-day U.S. Park Police investigation into the case, FBI participation was significant. Attorney Clarke's letter argues, "The publicly available federal government record upon which the Fiske Report is based is replete with evidence that the FBI concealed the true facts surrounding Mr. Foster's death."
The Arkansas Project
On May 2, 1999, the Washington Post published new details on the pursuit of a Foster conspiracy in an article by David Brock, a key figure in the Troopergate and Whitewater scandals whose disillusionment with the political corruption motivating what would come to be known as the Arkansas Project ended his lifelong commitment to the Conservative movement and facilitated public dissemination of insider details on G.O.P. machinations. The article explains how Brock was "summoned" to a meeting with Rex Armistead in Miami, Florida at an airport hotel. Brock claims that Armistead laid out for him an elaborate "Vince Foster murder scenario" – a scenario that he found implausible.
The Clinton Chronicles: A Political Firestorm
This reintroduction of Ruddy's ideas followed the publication of another book, penned by veteran crime reporter Dan Moldea, titled A Washington Tragedy: How the Death of Vincent Foster Ignited a Political Firestorm. Moldea was approached in 1997 by Regnery Publishing House, a famously conservative group whose leadership was nevertheless impressed by Moldea's published works, including an exhaustive critique of LAPD Detective Mark Fuhrman, another Regnery author.
In researching the debacle created by and surrounding Foster's death, Moldea found that the most oft-used conspiracy scenario could be traced back to Park Police Major Robert Hines, who shared the idea with Reed Irvine (Accuracy in Media) and Christopher Ruddy (New York Post). Moldea concludes, and Maj. Hines publicly maintains, that Hines incorrectly told Irvine and Ruddy "... that there is no exit wound in Foster's head ... I don't think there was anything nefarious here; he was being approached by reporters and he wanted something to say." Still, the "missing" exit wound claim continued to surface.
Moldea's research sought, among other things, to discover the origins of this line of investigation into the Clintons' credibility. In an interview for Salon.com, he suggests that "Foster had some blond hair and carpet fibers on his suit jacket, and he had semen in his underwear. So, the Jerry Falwells and the right-wing crowd get a hold of this information, and…they start making movies alleging that the Clintons were involved in this murder."
In 1994, Falwell subsidized the creation of a film called The Clinton Chronicles that featured Ruddy's claims that the gun that killed Foster was placed in his hand after the fact, and that Foster's body was laid out to give the appearance of suicide, among others. Funding for the film was provided by Citizens for Honest Government, an organization to which Falwell gave $200,000 in 1994 and 1995.
Citizens for Honest Government covertly paid individuals who had provided information to media outlets such as the Wall Street Journal editorial page and the American Spectator magazine;" and in 1995, made discretionary payments to two Arkansas state troopers who had spoken out in support of the idea of a conspiracy surrounding Foster's death. The two troopers, Roger Perry and Larry Patterson, had also previously given testimony supporting Paula Jones' claims of sexual misconduct and misuse of government resources against Bill Clinton (see Troopergate).
Patrick Matrisciana, president of Citizens for Honest Government, produced The Clinton Chronicles video and appeared in its commercials as an "investigative reporter" where he and Rev. Falwell engaged in the following exchange:
Falwell: "Could you please tell me and the American people why you think that your life and the lives of the others on this video are in danger?"
Matrisciana: "Jerry, two weeks ago we had an interview with a man who was an insider; his plane crashed and he was killed an hour before the interview. You may say this is just a coincidence, but there was another fellow that we were also going to interview, and he was killed in a plane crash. Jerry, are these coincidences? I don't think so."
When asked about the spot, Matrisciana admitted he was not a reporter and replied "I doubt our lives were actually ever in any real danger. That was Jerry's idea to do that ... He thought that would be dramatic."
A draft of a resignation letter, was found torn into 27 pieces after his death in a briefcase that had already been searched at least once. One piece, which may have contained a signature, was missing. William Safire referred in The New York Times to "the so-called suicide note, which appeared belatedly in 27 pieces, not one with a fingerprint, and with the signature space missing" The full text of the note is as follows:
I made mistakes from ignorance, inexperience and overwork
I did not knowingly violate any law or standard of conduct
No one in The White House, to my knowledge, violated any law or standard of conduct, including any action in the travel office. There was no intent to benefit any individual or specific group
The FBI lied in their report to the AG
The press is covering up the illegal benefits they received from the travel staff
The GOP has lied and misrepresented its knowledge and role and covered up a prior investigation
The Ushers Office plotted to have excessive costs incurred, taking advantage of Kaki and HRC
The public will never believe the innocence of the Clintons and their loyal staff
The WSJ editors lie without consequence
I was not meant for the job or the spotlight of public life in Washington. Here ruining people is considered sport.
Associate White House counsel, Steve Neuwirth, discovered the torn pieces of the note in Foster's briefcase on July 26. After receiving the note from Neuwirth, White House Counsel Bernard Nussbaum handled the note various times before giving it to Park Police Lieutenant Joseph Megby the following evening.
The United States Department of Justice revealed the note's contents at a joint press conference with the Park Police on August 10. The DoJ stated that a smudged palm print was on the note, but no fingerprints; they confirmed the handwriting as Foster's. Independent Counsel Robert Ray's report regarding the Whitewater controversy stated the FBI Laboratory performed a 1995 fingerprint examination of the note and identified Nussbaum's palm print on it. The report stated that three separate handwriting analyses of the note by the Capitol Police and the FBI determined that the handwriting on the note was Foster's.
- Failure of the Public Trust, John Clarke, Patrick J. Knowlton, Hugh Turley, September 14, 1999, ISBN-10: 096735210X
- Altered evidence in Foster death?, August 19, 2000, Charles Smith, WorldNetDaily
- Vince Foster's death: An FBI cover-up?, Zoh Hieronimus, August 19, 2000, WorldNetDaily
- Death of Vince Foster, October 16, 2004, Miquel Rodriguez (interviewed), Accuracy in Media
- Full text of the report on the 1993 death of White House counsel Vincent W. Foster, Jr., compiled by Whitewater independent counsel Kenneth Starr, fbicover-up.com; accessed January 16, 2017.
- FBI document Vince Foster, part 3 of 4, page 19, fbi.gov; accessed January 16, 2017.
- Report of Independent Counsel Fiske In Re Vincent W. Foster Jr. FBI Vince Foster part 1 of 4, page 193, fbi.gov; accessed January 16, 2017.
- Official Report, vol 2, pp. 4-7 University of Michigan, HATHItrust.org; accessed January 16, 2017.
- S.Res.229-103rd Congress Section 1. Scope of the hearings, (1), (B)
- Report: Starr Rules Out Foul Play In Foster Death CNN February 23, 1997
- Brookhiser, Richard (September 28, 1997). "Body Politics". The New York Times. Retrieved June 12, 2016.<templatestyles src="Module:Citation/CS1/styles.css"></templatestyles>
- Hohmann, Leo (February 28, 2016). "Vince Foster 'suicide' shocker: 2nd wound documented". WND. Retrieved June 12, 2016.<templatestyles src="Module:Citation/CS1/styles.css"></templatestyles>
- "Miguel Rodriguez US attorney Vincent Foster death investigator resignation letter". Citizen News. April 24, 2015. Retrieved June 12, 2016.<templatestyles src="Module:Citation/CS1/styles.css"></templatestyles>
- WRRK radio interview, fbicover-up.com, December 7, 1995.
- Media ByPass article, fbicover-up.com, October 1995.
- FBI Agent Bransford interview report (April 21, 1994) and Independent Counsel notes (November 13, 1995), fbicover-up.com; accessed January 16, 2017.
- Judge Butzner comments, fbicover-up.com, September 25, 1997.
- Judge Fay's handwritten note re: Motion by Patrick Knowlton
- Court order September 26, 1997
- Starr's Appeal to the Special Division, fbicover-up.com, September 29, 1997.
- Starr's motion denied, fbicover-up.com, September 30, 1997.
- "'Arkansas Project' Led to Turmoil and Rifts". Washington Post: A24. May 2, 1999. Retrieved 2006-05-03.<templatestyles src="Module:Citation/CS1/styles.css"></templatestyles>
- Lori Leibovich, "Why Vincent Foster can't rest in peace", Salon.com, May 28, 1998.
- Murray WaasThe Falwell connection, Salon.com, March 11, 1998.
- Johnston, David; Lewis, Neil (February 4, 1994). "Report Suggests Clinton Counsel Hampered Suicide Investigation". The New York Times. Retrieved July 30, 2017.
...One investigator said he had watched Mr. Nussbaum inspect the briefcase earlier without finding the note....<templatestyles src="Module:Citation/CS1/styles.css"></templatestyles>
- "Foster's Ghost", nytimes.com, Jnauary 6, 1994; accessed July 27, 2017.
- Comprehensive Textbook of Suicidology. Guilford Press. 2000. p. 281. ISBN 1-57230-541-X.<templatestyles src="Module:Citation/CS1/styles.css"></templatestyles>
- Ray, Robert W. (January 5, 2001). "Part E: The Discovery and Removal of Documents from Vincent W. Foster Jr.'s Office" (pdf). Final Report of the Independent Counsel in Re Madison Guaranty Savings and Loan Association. III. Washington, D.C.: United States Government Publishing Office. p. 277. Retrieved July 31, 2017.<templatestyles src="Module:Citation/CS1/styles.css"></templatestyles>
- Final Report of the Independent Counsel in Re Madison Guaranty Savings and Loan Association, Volume III, Part E 2001, p. 278.
- Apple Jr., R. W. (August 11, 1993). "Note Left by White House Aide: Accusation, Anger and Despair". The New York Times. Retrieved July 31, 2017.<templatestyles src="Module:Citation/CS1/styles.css"></templatestyles>
- Moldea, Dan E. (1998). A Washington Tragedy: How the Death of Vincent Foster Ignited a Political Firestorm. Regnery Publishing. p. 367. Retrieved July 30, 2017.
“…A fingerprint analysis of Foster's note by the FBI also reveals…that the palm print found on the note had been left by Bernard Nussbaum….”<templatestyles src="Module:Citation/CS1/styles.css"></templatestyles>
- Hugh Sprunt, Citizen's Independent Report: Material Errors, Omissions, Inconsistencies, & Curiosa
- John Clarke, Patrick Knowlton and Hugh Turley. "Failure of the Public Trust", McCabe Publishing, 1999; ISBN 0-9673521-0-X
- David Brock, Blinded by the Right : The Conscience of an Ex-Conservative, Three Rivers Press, 2003.
- Clinton, Bill (2005). My Life: Bill Clinton, Vintage Publishing; ISBN 1-4000-3003-X
- Joe Conason and Gene Lyons, The Hunting of the President: The Ten-Year Campaign to Destroy Bill and Hillary Clinton. St. Martin's Press, 2001; ISBN 0-312-27319-3
- Dan Moldea. A Washington Tragedy: How the Death of Vincent Foster Ignited a Political Firestorm, Regnery Publishing, 1998
- Ambrose Evans-Pritchard, The Secret Life of Bill Clinton, Regnery Publishing, 1999; ISBN 978-0-89526-408-4
- Christopher Ruddy. The Strange Death of Vincent Foster: An Investigation, Free Press, 2002; ISBN 978-0-74324-253-0
- Report on the Death of Vincent W. Foster, Jr,/by the Office of Independent Counsel in Re Madison Guaranty Savings and Loan Association HATHI Trust Digital Library, Universities of Michigan and Purdue, the complete 137 page, 2 vol. report with app., footnotes, and exhibits
- Once Upon a Time in Arkansas: Vince Foster's journal from Frontline
- Foster Report posted by The Washington Post (NOTE: This file does not contain the report's footnotes or appendix)
- Allan Favish website, allanfavish.com; accessed January 16, 2017.
- Nancy Benac (July 21, 1993). "White House Attorney An Apparent Suicide". Daily Sitka Sentinel. p. 7. Retrieved July 25, 2017 – via newspapers.com.<templatestyles src="Module:Citation/CS1/styles.css"></templatestyles>