The Goose-Step (book)
|Publisher||Self (Pasadena, California)|
|Media type||Print (Hardcover first edition, softcover second edition)
Reprinted 2004 by Kessinger Publishing in paperback
|Preceded by||The Brass Check|
|Followed by||The Goslings|
The Goose-step: A Study of American Education is a book, published in 1923, by the American novelist and muckraking journalist Upton Sinclair. It is an investigation into the consequences of plutocratic capitalist control of American colleges and universities. Sinclair writes, “Our educational system is not a public service, but an instrument of special privilege; its purpose is not to further the welfare of mankind, but merely to keep America capitalist." (p. 18)
The book is one of the “Dead Hand” series: six books Sinclair wrote on American institutions. The series also includes The Profits of Religion, The Brass Check (journalism), The Goslings (elementary and high school education), Mammonart (great literature, art and music) and Money Writes! (literature). The term “Dead Hand” criticizes Adam Smith’s concept that allowing an "invisible hand" of capitalist greed to shape economic relations provides the best result for society as a whole.
Published in 1923, The Goose-step was written during the post–World War I Red Scare. It was a time of great political awareness and activism on both left and right in the United States. On the left, there was widespread interest in Socialism and Communism, especially in the results of the 1917 Russian Revolution. Populist ideas were still alive, and Anarchism was in the news, with the Italian anarchists Sacco and Vanzetti arraigned in 1920 for a robbery and murder. On the right, the anti-German jingoism and florid patriotism of the war years had stirred up passions against pacifism and ‘foreign’ ideas such as Socialism and Communism. The Palmer raids against suspected radicals occurred in 1919, and superpatriotic organizations like the business-sponsored, anti-union Better America Foundation worked to shape public opinion.
Sinclair spent a year traveling the country for the book and interviewed over a thousand persons. (Like American filmmaker Michael Moore, Sinclair makes the rejection he received part of the story.) Sinclair also used primary sources like letters, and secondary sources like student newspapers.
Sinclair originally intended to also critique elementary and high schools, but because of length he saved that material for another book, published in 1924 as The Goslings.
Contemporary readers would have recognized the title, The Goose-step, as referring to the authoritarian Prussian culture of Germany, which the United States had recently defeated in World War I. With the title, Sinclair implies that students in American universities and colleges were being trained to think in unison like German students. This is not surprising, he implies, as the presidents of major universities--Princeton, Columbia, Harvard, Pennsylvania, Yale, University of California-Berkeley and Stanford (p. 115), and the chancellor of New York University (p. 314)--had studied in Germany. “Everyone (sic) of them learned the Goose-step under the Kaiser!” (p. 115)
- "Interlocking directorates" are "the device whereby three great banks in New York, with two trust companies under their control, manage the financial affairs and direct the policies of a hundred and twelve key corporations of America. The three banks are J. P. Morgan and Company, the First National Bank, and the National City Bank; and the two trust companies are the Guaranty and the Equitable. Their directors sit upon the boards of the corporations, sometimes several on each board, and their orders are obeyed because they control credit, which is the life-blood of our business world." (p. 19)
The interlocking directorate was equally well represented on the boards of trustees of American universities. Sinclair cites a survey by Evans Clark, "a preceptor in Princeton University--until he made this survey." Of the boards of the 29 largest universities, "the plutocratic class…composed 56 per cent of the membership of the privately controlled boards, and 68 per cent of the publicly controlled boards.” In contrast, the board members included 4-6 per cent farmers, no representatives of labor, and no inhouse professors to represent the faculty. (Clark's findings were confirmed by a 1917 study by Scott Nearing.)
For each school (see below), Sinclair describes how the interlocking directorate exercises its influence on the school's Board of Trustees. Bankers and powerful local businessmen dominate the boards, ensuring that school policies support their class interest.
This occurs in various ways. The school president serves the board rather than the educational interest of the students. Unqualified but politically conservative men are hired as administrators or professors. University funds are invested at artificially low interest rates at favored banks. Schools purchase land from people in their administration. The administration represses radical students and prohibits speeches by Socialists like Sinclair. Students at state universities, which are funded by the public, are nevertheless taught to serve the interests of the rich.
A major theme is professors' inability to speak freely in or out of class without fearing for their jobs (academic freedom). Rather, the Board of Trustees, acting through the school's president, suppressed any criticism of the status quo. Many faculty members were dismissed, driven out or denied promotion because of their political activities or views. Sinclair says that academic freedom was suppressed at church-sponsored and tax-supported (state) schools, as well as at private ones. Only one or two faculty members allowed Sinclair to use their names.
- "I talked with another professor at Chicago, who does not want his name used. I asked him what he thought about the status of his profession, and he gave the best description of academic freedom in America that I have yet come upon. He said, 'We are good cows; we stand quietly in our stanchions, and give down our milk at regular hours. We are free, because we have no desire to do anything but what we are told we ought to do. And we die of premature senility.'" (p. 247)
Other chapters deal with the importance of keeping the support of wealthy and politically conservative alumni/donors, and the influence of plutocrat-founded policy organizations like Andrew Carnegie's Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching and John D. Rockefeller’s General Education Board. A chapter, "The Academic Pogrom," concerns some institutions’ efforts to reduce the number of Jewish students and applicants. Final chapters support the alternative of workers’ education and labor colleges.
Among his prescriptions for change, Sinclair wanted more professors to unionize by joining the American Association of University Professors (only 2-3 per cent were unionized). He also wanted college students to experience real life: they should visit jails and work in factories, or alternatively have prisoners and labor leaders speak at their schools.
Critics have usually praised The Goose-step for bringing an enormous mass of information together in an engaging and readable book. It is “muckraking at its best”, an “honest effort to find out the truth” and "indispensable to any student of present American life." While they rarely if ever find errors of fact, they criticize Sinclair's interpretation as oversimplified: plutocrats are not responsible for all the problems with higher education.
Regarding suppression of academic freedom, one critic argues that “many [cases], perhaps a majority, were the result of war hysteria and should not be regarded as typical.”
Sinclair's epithet for the school follows; it refers to the major source of plutocratic influence on the Board of Directors or school administration.
- Columbia University: The University of the House of Morgan
- Harvard University: The University of Lee-Higginson
- University of Pennsylvania: The University of U.G.I. (United Gas Improvement Company)
- Princeton University: The Tiger’s Lair
- Yale University: The Bull-Dog’s Den
- University of California (Berkeley): The University of the Black Hand
- Stanford University
- Reed College, University of Oregon (Eugene): The University of the Lumber Trust
- University of Washington (Seattle): The University of the Chimes
- University of Montana (four schools): The Universities of the Anaconda
- University of Idaho (Moscow)
- University of Utah: The University of the Latter Day Saints
- University of Denver: The Mining Camp University
- Colorado College, Colorado School of Mines: The Colleges of the Smelter Trust
- North Dakota Agricultural College
- University of North Dakota-Grand Forks: The University of Wheat
- University of Minnesota: The University of the Ore Trust
- University of Wisconsin–Madison
- University of Chicago: The University of Standard Oil
- Northwestern University: The University of Judge Gary
- University of Illinois (Urbana): The University of the Grand Duchess (Mary E. Busey, widow of Samuel Busey)
- University of Michigan (Detroit): The University of Automobiles
- University of Pittsburgh: The University of the Steel Trust
- Syracuse University: The University of Heaven
- Clark University
- Johns Hopkins University
- Cornell University
- Brown University
- Wesleyan University
- New York University: The University of Jabbergrab
- City Colleges of New York (College of the City of New York: men; Hunter College: women)
- University of Southern California: Notably absent from his critiques was the University of Southern California, which Sinclair praised for its commitment to free-thinking. He was an avid Trojan football fan and wore a cardinal and gold colored tie every Saturday during college football season. He also dreamed that his daughters would be USC cheer leaders, a contradiction with his political values.
Briefer references to: MIT, Cincinnati, Washington University, Temple, Nebraska, Oklahoma, Iowa, Ohio State, Beloit, Marietta College, Rockford College, Williams College, Delaware, Bryn Mawr. Religious colleges: Wooster, Muskingum, Allegheny, Washburn, American University, Trinity, Baylor, SMU, Bethany, Emory and Henry
Institutions Sinclair praises: Union Theological Seminary, Berkeley Divinity School (Middletown CT), Oberlin, Iliff School of Theology (Denver), Y.M.C.A. College (Springfield, MA), Harvard Law, Amherst, Swarthmore, University of North Carolina, New School for Social Research
All page numbers refer to the second edition (1923).
The cited references can be found through JSTOR, an online database of academic journals.
- Hicks, Granville, "The Survival of Upton Sinclair" College English 4 (4) (Jan., 1943), 213-20.
- Alvord, Clarence W., The Goose-Step (Review), The Mississippi Valley Historical Review 10 (3) (Dec., 1923), pp. 336-7.
- Lovett, Robert Morss, "Upton Sinclair," The English Journal 17 (9) (Nov., 1928), 706-14.
- The Commercial Federation of California, renamed the Better America Federation in 1920 and well funded by large corporate interests, was "a kind of black hand society of the rich." The Commercial Federation had been founded by Harry Haldeman, a Los Angeles businessman (and grandfather of H. R. Haldeman). (p. 129)
- "Jabbergrab: Heroes of Finance" is a publication Sinclair invented for a satirical short story titled "A Captain of Industry."
Also Eells, Walter Crosby, "Criticisms of Higher Education", The Journal of Higher Education, 5 (4) (Apr. 1934), pp. 187–9.
- "Upton Sinclair’s criticism of higher education in America: A study of the The Goose-step, its sources, critical history, and relationship to criticisms of higher education." A Ph.D. dissertation in the history of education by Abraham Blinderman at New York University (1963). Dissertation Abstracts International, 25, no. 04, (1963): 2334. Accession No: AAG6406547.
- A book review by Russell Jacoby in the Los Angeles Times on June 19, 2005 discusses the current commercialization of academia. Available through Proquest (subscription required).
- A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the National Council for the Social Studies (64th, Washington, DC, November 15–19, 1984). "Upton Sinclair and the New Critics of Education" by Jack L Nelson. Abstract: Upton Sinclair's critique of education is examined, and what today's critics of education can learn from him is discussed. Available online through ERIC, Accession no. ED260954 (subscription required).