Rank |
Player |
Teams |
Seasons |
Games |
PIMs |
1 |
Tiger Williams |
Toronto, Vancouver, Detroit, Los Angeles, Hartford |
14 |
962 |
3,971 |
2 |
Dale Hunter |
Quebec, Washington, Colorado Avalanche |
19 |
1,407 |
3,565 |
3 |
Tie Domi |
Toronto, N.Y. Rangers, Winnipeg (original), Toronto |
16 |
1,020 |
3,515 |
4 |
Marty McSorley |
Pittsburgh, Edmonton, Los Angeles, Pittsburgh, Los Angeles, NY Rangers, San Jose, Edmonton, Boston |
17 |
961 |
3,381 |
5 |
Bob Probert |
Detroit, Chicago |
16 |
935 |
3,300 |
6 |
Rob Ray |
Buffalo, Ottawa |
15 |
900 |
3,207 |
7 |
Craig Berube |
Philadelphia, Toronto, Calgary, Washington, Philadelphia, Washington, N.Y. Islanders, Calgary |
17 |
1,054 |
3,149 |
8 |
Tim Hunter |
Calgary, Quebec, Vancouver, San Jose |
16 |
815 |
3,146 |
9 |
Chris Nilan |
Montreal, N.Y. Rangers, Boston, Montreal |
13 |
688 |
3,043 |
Rank |
Player |
Team(s) |
Seasons |
Games |
PIMs |
10 |
Rick Tocchet |
Philadelphia, Pittsburgh, Los Angeles, Boston, Washington, Phoenix, Philadelphia |
18 |
1,144 |
2,972 |
11 |
Pat Verbeek |
New Jersey, Hartford, N.Y. Rangers, Dallas, Detroit, Dallas |
20 |
1,424 |
2,905 |
12 |
Chris Chelios |
Montreal, Chicago, Detroit, Atlanta Thrashers |
26 |
1,651 |
2,891 |
13 |
Dave Manson |
Chicago, Edmonton, Winnipeg/Phoenix, Montreal, Chicago, Dallas, Toronto, Dallas |
16 |
1,103 |
2,792 |
14 |
Scott Stevens |
Washington, St. Louis, New Jersey |
22 |
1,635 |
2,785 |
15 |
Donald Brashear |
Montreal, Vancouver, Philadelphia, Washington, N.Y. Rangers |
16 |
1,025 |
2,634 |
16 |
Willi Plett |
Atlanta/Calgary Flames, Minnesota North Stars, Boston |
13 |
834 |
2,572 |
17 |
Gino Odjick |
Vancouver, N.Y. Islanders, Philadelphia, Montreal |
12 |
605 |
2,567 |
18 |
Matthew Barnaby |
Buffalo, Pittsburgh, Tampa Bay, N.Y. Rangers, Colorado Avalanche, Chicago, Dallas |
14 |
834 |
2,562 |
19 |
Gary Roberts |
Calgary, Carolina, Toronto, Florida, Pittsburgh, Tampa Bay |
21 |
1,224 |
2,560 |
20 |
Chris Neil |
Ottawa |
15 |
1,026 |
2,522 |
21 |
Joe Kocur |
Detroit, N.Y. Rangers, Vancouver, Detroit |
15 |
820 |
2,519 |
22 |
Ken Daneyko |
New Jersey |
20 |
1,283 |
2,516 |
Rank |
Player |
Team(s) |
Seasons |
Games |
PIMs |
23 |
Brendan Shanahan |
New Jersey, St. Louis, Hartford, Detroit, N.Y. Rangers, New Jersey |
21 |
1,524 |
2,489 |
24 |
Scott Mellanby |
Philadelphia, Edmonton, Florida, St. Louis, Atlanta Thrashers |
21 |
1,431 |
2,479 |
25 |
Basil McRae |
Quebec, Toronto, Detroit, Quebec, Minnesota North Stars, Tampa Bay, St. Louis, Chicago |
16 |
576 |
2,457 |
26 |
Ulf Samuelsson |
Hartford, Pittsburgh, N.Y. Rangers, Detroit, Philadelphia |
16 |
1,080 |
2,453 |
27 |
Jeff Odgers |
San Jose, Boston, Colorado Avalanche, Atlanta Thrashers |
12 |
821 |
2,364 |
28 |
Jay Wells |
Los Angeles, Philadelphia, Buffalo, N.Y. Rangers, St. Louis, Tampa Bay |
18 |
1,098 |
2,359 |
29 |
Shayne Corson |
Montreal, Edmonton, St. Louis, Montreal, Toronto, Dallas |
19 |
1,156 |
2,357 |
30 |
Lyle Odelein |
Montreal, New Jersey, Phoenix, Columbus, Chicago, Dallas, Florida, Pittsburgh |
16 |
1,056 |
2,316 |
31 |
Bryan Marchment |
Winnipeg (original), Chicago, Hartford, Edmonton, Tampa Bay, San Jose, Colorado Avalanche, Toronto, Calgary |
17 |
926 |
2,307 |
32 |
Garth Butcher |
Vancouver, St. Louis, Quebec, Toronto |
14 |
897 |
2,302 |
33 |
Shane Churla |
Hartford, Calgary, Minnesota/Dallas, Los Angeles, N.Y. Rangers |
11 |
488 |
2,301 |
34 |
Kelly Buchberger |
Edmonton, Atlanta Thrashers, Los Angeles, Phoenix, Pittsburgh |
18 |
1,182 |
2,297 |
35 |
Dave Schultz |
Philadelphia, Los Angeles, Pittsburgh, Buffalo |
9 |
535 |
2,294 |
36 |
Laurie Boschman |
Toronto, Edmonton, Winnipeg (original), New Jersey, Ottawa |
14 |
1,009 |
2,263 |
Rank |
Player |
Team(s) |
Seasons |
Games |
PIMs |
37 |
Brad May |
Buffalo, Vancouver, Phoenix, Vancouver, Colorado, Anaheim, Toronto, Detroit |
18 |
1,041 |
2,248 |
38 |
Ken Baumgartner |
Los Angeles, N.Y. Islanders, Toronto, Anaheim, Boston |
12 |
696 |
2,244 |
39 |
Kevin Dineen |
Hartford, Philadelphia, Hartford/Carolina, Ottawa, Columbus |
19 |
1,188 |
2,229 |
40 |
Rob Ramage |
Colorado Rockies, St. Louis, Calgary, Toronto, Minnesota North Stars, Tampa Bay, Montreal, Philadelphia |
15 |
1,044 |
2,226 |
41 |
Keith Tkachuk |
Winnipeg/Phoenix, St. Louis, Atlanta Thrashers, St. Louis |
18 |
1,201 |
2,219 |
42 |
Bryan Watson |
Montreal, Detroit, Montreal, Oakland, Pittsburgh, St. Louis, Detroit, Washington |
16 |
878 |
2,212 |
43 |
Steve Smith |
Edmonton, Chicago, Calgary |
16 |
804 |
2,139 |
44 |
Stu Grimson |
Calgary, Chicago, Anaheim, Detroit, Hartford/Carolina, Anaheim, Los Angeles, Nashville |
14 |
729 |
2,113 |
45 |
Terry O'Reilly |
Boston |
14 |
891 |
2,095 |
46 |
Al Secord |
Boston, Chicago, Toronto, Philadelphia, Chicago |
12 |
766 |
2,093 |
47 |
Zdeno Chára |
N.Y. Islanders, Ottawa, Boston, Washington |
24 |
1,680 |
2,085 |
48 |
Ronnie Stern |
Vancouver, Calgary, San Jose |
12 |
638 |
2,077 |
49 |
Mick Vukota |
N.Y. Islanders, Tampa Bay, Montreal |
11 |
573 |
2,071 |
50 |
Gord Donnelly |
Quebec, Winnipeg (original), Buffalo, Dallas |
12 |
554 |
2,069 |
51 |
Luke Richardson |
Toronto, Edmonton, Philadelphia, Columbus, Toronto, Tampa Bay, Ottawa |
21 |
1,417 |
2,055 |
52 |
Mike Foligno |
Detroit, Buffalo, Toronto, Florida |
15 |
1,018 |
2,049 |
53 |
Phil Russell |
Chicago, Atlanta/Calgary, New Jersey, Buffalo |
15 |
1,016 |
2,038 |
54 |
Kris King |
Detroit, N.Y. Rangers, Winnipeg/Phoenix, Toronto, Chicago |
14 |
849 |
2,030 |
55 |
Kelly Chase |
St. Louis, Hartford, Toronto, St. Louis |
11 |
458 |
2,017 |
56 |
Harold Snepsts |
Vancouver, Minnesota North Stars, Detroit, Vancouver, St. Louis |
17 |
1,033 |
2,009 |